Rescue Show Guide
company

The Profit · Season 5, Episode 4 · Aired December 12, 2017

Monica Potter Home

Garrettsville, Ohio

CLOSED

Closed. The business shut its doors in 2017.

What happened after

Actress Monica Potter's home/lifestyle storefront in downtown Garrettsville (The Arcade) closed permanently; owner cited difficulty running the store while based in Los Angeles, said she would focus online.

Closure date on record: 2017-07

What happened on the show

Monica Potter Home was a home goods store that the Parenthood actress Monica Potter had opened near her family in rural Ohio, and its central problem was one of control. Potter did not have the time to run the store herself, yet could not bring herself to hand the reins to any of her employees, least of all her own sister, and the resulting chaos ran high on emotion. The episode became as much about repairing family relationships as about retail, with Marcus trying to bring order and focus to a brand that risked vanishing in the disorder. It fit a recurring Profit pattern, a business built on a personal story and a famous name that still needed the basic structure and delegation any store requires to survive. The affection behind it was real, but affection alone does not run a shop.

After the cameras left

The physical store closed. Monica Potter's home and lifestyle storefront in downtown Garrettsville shut permanently in July 2017, with the owner citing the difficulty of running it from Los Angeles and saying she would shift her focus online, per coverage from Cleveland area outlets. We could not confirm the current status of any online only continuation of the brand, since the site returned access errors and a search summary claiming ongoing retail conflicted with the closure reporting. The brick and mortar closure is well documented. Confirmed storefront closure as of 2017, medium confidence.

Sources

Confidence: medium. Last checked 2026-07-19.

More from The Profit

See the full list