Rescue Show Guide
restaurant

Restaurant Stakeout · Season 3, Episode 5 · Aired April 15, 2013

The Bayou

North Bellmore, New York

CLOSED

It has since closed in 2018.

What happened after

Cajun/Creole restaurant since 1986, "Long Island's longest-running New Orleans-style restaurant"; owner Lisa Livermore posted on Facebook (Nov 3, 2018): "It is with a heavy heart I announce The Bayou will be permanently closed in its current location in Bellmore."

Closure date on record: 2018-11

What happened on the show

Lisa was the owner at the center of Degel's North Bellmore stakeout of The Bayou, a Cajun and Creole room the episode framed as anything but easy to fix. The hidden cameras captured the floor when management assumed no one was watching, and as aired the footage gave Degel a documented case about where the operation was breaking down. His confrontation used that evidence to press Lisa on leadership and consistency, while his fixes brought the familiar reset of systems and standards. The stakeout followed the format's central promise, using surveillance to convert an owner's sense that something was wrong into a specific, documented picture of the room's failings, the necessary first step before Degel would attempt any repair on the struggling Long Island room.

After the cameras left

The Bayou has closed. Billed as Long Island's longest running New Orleans style restaurant and open since 1986, it announced its permanent closure in a heartfelt Facebook post from owner Lisa Livermore in November 2018, after thirty two years at the Jerusalem Avenue address in Bellmore. The self reported farewell makes this a high confidence closure. A long lived Cajun institution that outlasted most of its rivals before finally winding down.

Sources

Confidence: high. Last checked 2026-07-19.

What is there now

Street imagery via Google Maps. Location approximate.

More from Restaurant Stakeout

See the full list