restaurantRestaurant Stakeout · Season 4, Episode 12 · Aired December 18, 2013
Division Street Grill
Peekskill, New York
It is still up and running.
What happened after
Active OpenTable listing (4/5, 282 reviews) in Historic Downtown Peekskill's Artist District; Facebook shows 928+ likes. Direct fetch of divisionstreetgrill.com failed on an SSL certificate/hostname mismatch (site infra issue, not necessarily a closure signal), so official-site content itself is not independently confirmed.
What happened on the show
Degel's second Peekskill stakeout, at the Division Street Grill, was framed around an owner who had lost his passion for the business. The hidden cameras captured the floor when management assumed no one was watching, and as aired the footage gave Degel a documented picture of how that fading interest showed up in the service and the operation. His confrontation used that evidence to press the owner on whether he still wanted the fine American room he had built, while his fixes brought the familiar reset of systems and standards. The stakeout followed one of the show's quieter themes, that a restaurant reflects the energy of the person at the top, and that the cameras exist to show a burned out owner exactly what his indifference was costing the floor.
After the cameras left
Division Street Grill is open. An active OpenTable listing with a solid rating across hundreds of reviews places the fine American restaurant in Peekskill's historic downtown, with a Facebook page carrying strong engagement and live jazz on weekends at the North Division Street address. A direct fetch of the restaurant's own domain failed on a certificate mismatch, so we hold the verdict at moderate confidence, but the OpenTable and social signals point clearly to an operating business worth a future re check.
Sources
Confidence: medium. Last checked 2026-07-19.
What is there now
Street imagery via Google Maps. Location approximate.